NASA Challenge: Develop 3D Models for Robonaut Simulation-Drill Battery and Charger

Public Clarification Board

• 

  plastmassive

  • 6 years ago

  I was just wondering why the first winner was disqualified?
  Btw, judging from the final winner's model, you did not require utmost precision, as it has been stated in your guidelines..

  • 6 years ago
  View 5 more messages
  1. 

     mehrdad72

     • 6 years ago

     its not good to say, but i could hardly upload my work, cuz of internet speed in my country, so i deny some of my assembly parts

     • 6 years ago
  2. 

     mehrdad72

     • 6 years ago

     goodluck with your gains,

     • 6 years ago
• 

  aoxsystems

  • 6 years ago

  Examining the winner submission, its nice render. But differs from the photos you sent. For example Battery charger front, compare photo and 3D Model (stuff above label, on 3d model there is 6 extruded parts, on photo 7 + extruded base where led lamp is stacioned ...there is no where to be seen on 3d model,

  • 6 years ago
  View 1 more message
  1. 
     Contest Holder

     • 6 years ago

     Indeed there were a number of excellent submissions and it was very difficult to select a winner.

     • 6 years ago
  2. 

     rickq

     • 6 years ago

     Hi aoxsystems, regard for you. I also not really happy regarding judging process. Actually I join 6 contest from Nasa. In some contest I am sure the winner is not real follow photograph. And @nasacoeci give some reason because ("where highly similar top submissions are produced, the submission entered first will win."). And I try to make it first submission with near to photograph in other contest, and again I'm loose. My suggestion to CH, please take a look more detail (like contour, parting line for plastic part, logo, etc) about your part and compare to all submission. Just suggest. But again, you are the judges. Thank you and no offence.

     • 6 years ago
• 

  mehrdad72

  • 6 years ago

  i cant understand why my work was unqualified? you should have explain me that before rejecting my work, its a shame

  • 6 years ago
• 

  mehrdad72

  • 6 years ago

  hi nasacoeci

  • 6 years ago
• 
  Contest Holder

  • 6 years ago

  Congratulations to BrianStandridge! Unfortunately (or fortunately for Brian) our original winner was disqualified. Thanks again for everyone's great entries.

  • 6 years ago
• 

  aoxsystems

  • 6 years ago

  What happened with the original winner? Also, I'm selling my 3D model #14 for very low price, so my work doesn't go completely in vein. If You are interested. There is an offer :) All best!

  • 6 years ago
• 

  xiaoxiaopu

  • 7 years ago

  Hi, nasacorci, I was tried to upload the pics, I uploaded everything, but when I click submit button, it's shows closed, just late for 1 mins I guess...it's there anyway I can send pics to you by email? Thanks!!

  • 7 years ago
  View 3 more messages
  1. 
     Contest Holder

     • 7 years ago

     Sorry to hear that. Thank you for all of your efforts and we hope you participate next time as well.

     • 7 years ago
  2. 
     Contest Holder

     • 7 years ago

     I did check out your board. Very nice work on the charger (although I didn't see the battery). Hopefully you will be able to use this model to showcase your skills which are clearly demonstrated with that model. Thanks again for your efforts.

     • 7 years ago
• 
  Contest Holder

  • 7 years ago

  Thank you to all of the Freelancers who participated in this challenge. You all demonstrated some amazing work. Great job mehrdad72! Congratulations!

  • 7 years ago
• 
  Contest Holder

  • 7 years ago

  Thanks for all of the amazing entries for this contest. We will be working over the next few days to evaluate them all and select the winner.

  • 7 years ago
• 

  shourodipto

  • 7 years ago

  Could you please extend the last date by a day or two? I just came across this and I would love to design this drill. :)

  • 7 years ago
  1. 
     Contest Holder

     • 7 years ago

     I would love to, but this contest is being run as part of a study that will compare results from the other 13 contest and duration is one of the variables that we need to keep constant. There are a couple of other contests we have the will run a couple more days.

     • 7 years ago
  2. 

     shourodipto

     • 7 years ago

     Thanks for replying. Enough said :)

     • 7 years ago
• 

  Anork

  • 7 years ago

  Uploaded another version. Thanks for your input.

  • 7 years ago
  1. 
     Contest Holder

     • 7 years ago

     Thanks!

     • 7 years ago
• 

  dn1eel

  • 7 years ago

  I will give it a try after work without the DeWalt stickers, i hope i can deliver it before midnight. In which version of SolidWorks do you need it made ?, thanks.

  • 7 years ago
  1. 
     Contest Holder

     • 7 years ago

     Great! Note that this contest still has another 9 days left. as far as version goes, it does not really matter as long as you can deliver in one of the following formats: .prt (Solidworks, ProE); .step or .stp; .iges; .stl; .dae. Good luck!

     • 7 years ago
  2. 

     csohlberg

     • 7 years ago

     Could this contest be split up? Say one has a better drill battery, but is lacking in the charger area as where another excels.

     • 7 years ago
• 

  isyfy

  • 7 years ago

  I won! DeWalt is a registered trademark. So any contest entries based on those images simply can not be original work. Luckily, I did not even look at those images for the drill, battery or battery charger. My 3D work is completely original using 100% open source resources right down to the operating system. So, in a polite manner, I declare victory, which makes perfect common sense.

  • 7 years ago
  1. 
     Contest Holder

     • 7 years ago

     "I'll have what he's having...."

     • 7 years ago
  2. 

     isyfy

     • 7 years ago

     Oh my goodness! NASA having the 3D models I have just created today is an honor! Yes, I accept! I will export from Blender 2.70 to formats: Collada (.DAE), Stanford (.PLY), and Stl (.STL). Thank you for your confidence in me.

     • 7 years ago
• 

  Anork

  • 7 years ago

  Hi! Kindly provide feedback for our latest entry!

  • 7 years ago
  1. 
     Contest Holder

     • 7 years ago

     Done.

     • 7 years ago
  2. 

     Anork

     • 7 years ago

     Uploaded some more render.

     • 7 years ago
• 

  Anork

  • 7 years ago

  Please provide some feedback.

  • 7 years ago
  1. 
     Contest Holder

     • 7 years ago

     Done.

     • 7 years ago
• 

  aoxsystems

  • 7 years ago

  Hi! Kindly waiting for feedback :)

  • 7 years ago
  1. 
     Contest Holder

     • 7 years ago

     Done.

     • 7 years ago
• 

  ershaaaad

  • 7 years ago

  please see my entry,,

  • 7 years ago
  1. 
     Contest Holder

     • 7 years ago

     Done.

     • 7 years ago
• 

  Akagu

  • 7 years ago

  Houston do we have a problem?

  • 7 years ago
  1. 
     Contest Holder

     • 7 years ago

     Akagu-Houston...Do you think we have a problem? Over...

     • 7 years ago
• 

  plastmassive

  • 7 years ago

  I understand, you need the models UV'd and textured (labels) to be used in some kind of animation/presentation? Otherwise I don't see why you need the labels and textures for grasp and robot manipulation testing.

  • 7 years ago
  View 1 more message
  1. 

     plastmassive

     • 7 years ago

     Thanks for the reply. Image recognition - right, haven't thought about it. That is so sci-fi!

     • 7 years ago
  2. 
     Contest Holder

     • 7 years ago

     We are hoping to make it more sci and less fi. :)

     • 7 years ago
• 
  Contest Holder

  • 7 years ago

  Quick question for the community. Do you prefer submissions for this kind of a contest to be sealed or unsealed?

  • 7 years ago
  1. 

     elounegaflah

     • 7 years ago

     sealed

     • 7 years ago
• 
  Contest Holder

  • 7 years ago

  We just uploaded a close up photo of the bottom of the battery.

  • 7 years ago
• 

  lpgiraudiraud

  • 7 years ago

  could you make a photo detail of the label on drill battery bottom please. We can't read all the details.

  • 7 years ago
  View 1 more message
  1. 

     lpgiraudiraud

     • 7 years ago

     thanks; i'm on it

     • 7 years ago
  2. 
     Contest Holder

     • 7 years ago

     We just uploaded a photo of the bottom of the battery.

     • 7 years ago
• 

  lpgiraudiraud

  • 7 years ago

  Hello,

  • 7 years ago
• 

  elounegaflah

  • 7 years ago

  What are the Stickers do i have to desing ?

  • 7 years ago
  View 1 more message
  1. 

     elounegaflah

     • 7 years ago

     to design* sorry
     do i have to put all the stickers ,shown in your picture, in the 3D model ?

     • 7 years ago
  2. 
     Contest Holder

     • 7 years ago

     Ah got it. While not mandatory, if there are two designs that are equivalent and one has decals/stickers, we would likely award to the more detailed. Since this is a contest, we are awarding to the best submission (i.e. closest to the photos).

     • 7 years ago

Show more comments