3D design of smart watch

Public Clarification Board

• 

  abdullahalbaki

  • 11 years ago

  I am reporting this contest because no designer would choose this rendering as winner. this does not even have the quality to be an entry of a contest.
  
  Complete cheating!!

  • 11 years ago
  View 20 more messages
  1. 
     Contest Holder

     • 11 years ago

     best of luck

     • 11 years ago
  2. 
     Contest Holder

     • 11 years ago

     you can't do anything than shout here. as it is a real contest. loosers always shout. hope, you can waste more of your time here.

     • 11 years ago
• 

  fluteandfeather

  • 11 years ago

  we have worked more than a week behind this project and at the end it was fake. A internet marketer #dineshroy who as posted his entry hours before closing of the projects gets selected. The watch that he made was completely out of what was the description(My dog shit is better than that watch) .
  Check this link - https://www.freelancer.com/projects/threed-animation-threed-modelling/model-Smart-watch.html
  It must have explain a lot.
  It is highly likely that #dineshroy and #flpriya know each other.
  I am not going to leave this so soon. I know that the project holder name is Priya Dharshini and she is from chennai, India. I am not going to leave them so soon. I will make sure my efforts gets calculated. I will take this issue to freelance and if need to the court.

  • 11 years ago
  View 23 more messages
  1. 

     victomig

     • 11 years ago

     It is very clear that this contest was a fraud, the "winner" does not meet your requirements, do not you know take the competition, and you are responsible, who's the jerk?

     • 11 years ago
  2. 
     Contest Holder

     • 11 years ago

     thanks

     • 11 years ago
• 

  airbrusheskid

  • 11 years ago

  you're right, and I worked five days on the project, no rating not given, is a fake, a jerk, can not be so, he chose someone who gave what he asked.

  • 11 years ago
  1. 
     Contest Holder

     • 11 years ago

     no rating = nothing good in your work, first understand that.

     • 11 years ago
  2. 

     echiepner

     • 11 years ago

     My work was also unrated, but rejected. And I am 100% sure any of these designers will agree that my work was good. And I am 110% sure they will all agree that some of the rejected and unrated designs are better than the winning design, which was submitted by a non-designer (i think thats super suspect). Please take a moment and reflect on your design knowledge, you will find it is not close to good enough to even think about judging any designs. Please refrain from critisizing any designs, as you have absolutely no design knowledge.

     • 11 years ago
• 

  juwin305

  • 11 years ago

  They wont anthing !!last time for a 1000$contest,ehen all the participants started reporting they delayed the handover process and ultimately send the money back to the fake CH and left him with 2 choices -either choose a different entry or post a new project... The guy did nothing i guess and took the money back.there is guarantee even it is a guaranteed contest...may be it is time to move on some other trusted sites.

  • 11 years ago
  View 5 more messages
  1. 

     echiepner

     • 11 years ago

     I contacted freelancer.com via the dropdown in the above menu. I will provide feedback if and when they respond.

     • 11 years ago
  2. 

     fluteandfeather

     • 11 years ago

     I know some websites which work on top 3 formula but again 3d work is very less to find.

     • 11 years ago
• 

  ossovw

  • 11 years ago

  but it's still 9 hours! I worked like a week on my 3d model and didn't even get a chance to post it!

  • 11 years ago
  View 2 more messages
  1. 

     jemzbenz

     • 11 years ago

     you're lucky he didn't get your design. logic tells me this is a plan to gather designs and not spend anything (besides the fees). just add it to your portfolio.

     • 11 years ago
  2. 

     echiepner

     • 11 years ago

     This will be a portfolio project for many designers. Some good work to be showcased... Pity that this contest is such a big joke.

     • 11 years ago
• 

  fluteandfeather

  • 11 years ago

  I will ask #freelancer to improve the system of holding a contest so that freelancer like us do not get cheated. I do not think freelancers who have given so much of time on this contest will ever be applying on any contest after this.

  • 11 years ago
  1. 

     echiepner

     • 11 years ago

     I feel that all of the LEGITIMATE designers should be given some sort of compensation for their time and effort.

     • 11 years ago
  2. 

     juwin305

     • 11 years ago

     totally !!.something has to be done .they must make a rule if the contest is claimed to be fake ,the prize money must be shared

     • 11 years ago
• 

  echiepner

  • 11 years ago

  Cannot believe the winning entry. collusion. cheat. unfair. intellectual property theft. I am livid, and feel everyone who entered this legitimately should be too.

  • 11 years ago
• 

  Western1979

  • 11 years ago

  Have read all your comments, just want to say before you go expecting freelancer.com to do anything about this you should know that they are just as dodgy. see the following link https://www.freelancer.co.za/contest/Design-FREELANCER-COM-Reception-Area-Interior-Design--70634.html.

  • 11 years ago
  View 1 more message
  1. 

     Western1979

     • 11 years ago

     meant to say custom.

     • 11 years ago
  2. 

     echiepner

     • 11 years ago

     That design should have won the contest. It was the best by a mile. This site is a joke.

     • 11 years ago
• 

  fluteandfeather

  • 11 years ago

  flpriya please tell me a way to provide the video 360 preview.

  • 11 years ago
  View 2 more messages
  1. 

     fluteandfeather

     • 11 years ago

     Aren't you ashamed of yourself asking for the link.

     • 11 years ago
  2. 
     Contest Holder

     • 11 years ago

     I just replied for your question, why should i get ashamed?

     • 11 years ago
• 

  Western1979

  • 11 years ago

  If you look by time submitted..dineshroy's entry was the 4th last entry. what a surprise. The sudden sealing of the contest says it all. Will be reporting

  • 11 years ago
• 

  jemzbenz

  • 11 years ago

  the winner is not even an artist, look at the profile

  • 11 years ago
• 

  code3D

  • 11 years ago

  I came to this site few months ago and now i see what's happening "behind the walls". I thought someone is standing behind these contests, some group of specialist who is constantly checking the legitimacy of projects. All of us put a lot of effort into this, someone didn't even got their chance to post their work, because this contest was closed 9 hour before the ending. I am asking myself, how can i ever trust any projects/contest on this site? We are not some group of people who have a spare time to play with something, we are specialist and we need some respect. This is a big shame and i really hope these guys will never get any chances to manipulate with anybody...never again. All i can say, congrats to all of you, amazing designs.

  • 11 years ago
• 

  Western1979

  • 11 years ago

  PS what was all that talk about making the watch round, and like a jewel. What a joke

  • 11 years ago
• 

  victomig

  • 11 years ago

  Hello, since we do not know if this was false competition, objectively, the winning design is very, very simple design that is inexpensive. Very little creativity. Really leaves in doubt the truth of who called this contest. From the point of view as a designer, there were better jobs.

  • 11 years ago
• 

  juwin305

  • 11 years ago

  i just want to mention here the names of "airbrusheslkid" who really spent a lot of effort and came up with something outstanding!! such an awesome design(unfortunately the fake CH who hosted up a fake contest did'nt have time even to give a rating even while it received 16 likes!!that is the firs time!) hats off to you airbrusheskid. i also like to say jmacdonald,echiepner,fluteandfeather many others did an awesome job. just saying .sorry if this have hurt the feelings of CH, but cant accept the fact that the entry was posted by a marketing guy who probably must have told you this idea of a high budget contest to steal designs

  • 11 years ago
• 

  juwin305

  • 11 years ago

  shitttt!!! it happened again.i remember the last time i came across a 1000$ "fake" contest. these days it is quiet hard to find legitimate contest.well, may be it is better to keep your eyes on the low budget ones!!.any way there were a lot of entries which were really good(which this guy will be using effectively)!!.this one here is not even a round design as he wanted!LOL...i wish the site would do something about this!!

  • 11 years ago
• 

  sdmoovarss

  • 11 years ago

  Hi flpriya, Entry #81 has copied my concepts. PLease refer to my entry #63 . the dial hand & pendant ring are just copied from mine. I hope you will give justification.!

  • 11 years ago
  1. 

     fluteandfeather

     • 11 years ago

     entry #63 is a static design and mine( #81 ) is very different. Mind your own work before pointing finger at someone's effort.

     • 11 years ago
• 

  echiepner

  • 11 years ago

  Hi flpriya, please rate the additional entries. Some designers put a lot of time and effort into their designs and any form of feedback would be greatly appreciated. Feedback helps desginers to keep up with your requirements as well as bettering our skills and understanding.

  • 11 years ago
  1. 

     daCotuA

     • 11 years ago

     Maybe he got struck by the lightning

     • 11 years ago
  2. 

     echiepner

     • 11 years ago

     Hahahahahahahahahaha! Seems like the chances are good. I thought my design was good, maybe the lightning affected the judgement...

     • 11 years ago
• 

  juwin305

  • 11 years ago

  Hi there,would you mind take a look over entry #82.thanks

  • 11 years ago
• 

  jmacdonald82

  • 11 years ago

  Hi flpriya, I've completed the amendments you asked for in my design. Please see #85 . Thanks.

  • 11 years ago
• 

  daCotuA

  • 11 years ago

  Cannot continue working without a feedback, don't no in which direction to go

  • 11 years ago
• 

  airbrusheskid

  • 11 years ago

  please check #76 ,#78.thanks

  • 11 years ago
• 

  fluteandfeather

  • 11 years ago

  Hello,

  • 11 years ago
  1. 

     fluteandfeather

     • 11 years ago

     Please provide feedback on entry no 64 and 81, Thanks

     • 11 years ago
• 

  daCotuA

  • 11 years ago

  Hi, I received an email, but I don't see the feedback? Regards

  • 11 years ago
• 

  echiepner

  • 11 years ago

  Hi flpriya, Please rate my entry #74 . Any feedback would be much appreciated.

  • 11 years ago
• 
  Contest Holder

  • 11 years ago

  AS I MENTIONED IN THE BRIEF, I WANT THE WATCH SHOULD BE HANDBOOK AS PENDANT, ATTACH IN CLOTHES ETC,

  • 11 years ago
• 

  Western1979

  • 11 years ago

  udayd75... your submissing is from a japanese stock model site. You know some people put alot of effort into these things and you pull a slimy move like that. I hope you never win anything here.....just saying.

  • 11 years ago
  View 1 more message
  1. 
     Contest Holder

     • 11 years ago

     i don't know why these people acting like this.

     • 11 years ago
  2. 

     chowdarydodda

     • 11 years ago

     good thing the contest was not sealed so that other people could find out if anyone is using a copied design.If this contest was sealed,then who would find out

     • 11 years ago
• 

  victomig

  • 11 years ago

  Hi, another design #75

  • 11 years ago

Show more comments