MYL Annual Report 2013

Name: MYL Annual Report 2013
Rating: 4.8 (29 reviews)

Status: Closed
Prize: $120
Entries Received: 42
Winner: Brandwar

Public Clarification Board

rmissin
- 12 years ago
Submitted #51 and #52 , I hope this is closer to your requirements.

thx
- 12 years ago
Contest Holder
- 12 years ago
Sadly I don't have the time to provide feedback to 20 different freelancers. Everyone has been given the same brief and we just have time unfortunately to provide limited feedback (which we did to you initially). Your understanding and respect is appreciated.

As to Primavaradin07, please don't vent your frustrations in our competition forum. If you have an issue with them please send your complaint to Freelancer.com directly.
- 12 years ago
View 1 more message
1. primavaradin07
  - 12 years ago
  Dear CH,
  
  it's just about fair-play here, not about frustrations. I am sure you noticed what ezesol did and you'll do the right thing. Thank you for understanding.
  - 12 years ago
2. rmissin
  - 12 years ago
  @ primavaradin07, the contest isn't over yet ;)
  - 12 years ago
rmissin
- 12 years ago
@ Contest Holder : Would you please take the time to provide some feedback on these designs,

1. What colours do you prefer on the cover ?
2. Do you want flat vector style or 3D ?

What is the point of rating something 2 or 3 stars and providing no feedback ? , that tells me nothing, you might as well reject them.
We are designers trying to understand what you want and provide you with your vision, without feedback it makes it very difficult.

thanks
- 12 years ago
primavaradin07
- 12 years ago
@ezesol
It's easy to steal somebody's idea, isn'it? I am sure that if it was a sealed contest, you wouldn't draw trees!
Shame on you! Exactly 6 trees???
- 12 years ago
1. rmissin
  - 12 years ago
  Yes, I noticed that yesterday, it's a blatant copy of your concept, he's switched from 3d trees to 2d vector after he saw your rating. It's soul destroying to work around here.
  - 12 years ago
rmissin
- 12 years ago
Why are entries being rated that have a huge great SHUTTERSTOCK Watermark in them ?
- 12 years ago
View 3 more messages
1. rmissin
  - 12 years ago
  OK, thanks for your reply, would it be possible for you to use the private message function in future ? "designers" around here have a habit of taking other peoples concepts. ;)
  I will revise the design.
  
  thanks
  - 12 years ago
2. primavaradin07
  - 12 years ago
  You're new, but you are damned right: ""designers" around here have a habit of taking other peoples concepts. ;)"
  Unfortunately, it's so true! And so sad! (see my earlier message)
  Good luck, brother!
  - 12 years ago
SagarChitrakar
- 12 years ago
#23 Clean, minimal and bold design. Please have a look
- 12 years ago
Denea
- 12 years ago
Hello , can you please feedback on #6 , #7 and tell me if there are things that need to be changed? Thanks, best regards.
- 12 years ago